Affordable Shelby County, Indiana Expungement Lawyer Stephanie Renner Free Consultation Felony & Misdemanor Expungement Attorney Shelbyville, Indiana

Do you have questions about the Indiana Expungement Law? Call the Indiana Expungement Queen, Stephanie Renner at 317-771-8535 or email me at [email protected] If you are emailing me, please provide your legal name(s) as it appears on mycase.in.gov as well as your date of birth so that I can pull your case files. I provide free consultations, affordable pricing, payment plans (including Buy Now Pay Later) and a MONEY BACK GUARANTEE ON ALL EXPUNGEMENTS. For most expungements, I can handle your Indiana expungement without you even having to show up for a court date. Do you think it all sounds too good to be true? Call my office for a free consultation to find out why they call me the Indiana Expungement Queen. I practice in the entire State of Indiana, including Marion County, Hamilton County, Hendricks County, Boone County, Monroe County, Madison County, Johnson County, Hancock County, Shelby County, Greenfield, Bloomington, Noblesville, Carmel, Fishers, Lebanon, Franklin, Shelbyville, Danville, and Plainfield, Indiana. Lets go over some basic information about the Indiana Expungement Law below.  Remember that the information below is a basic summary of Indiana Law and does not contain every possible exception.  It is important to talk about your case with an Indiana Expungement Attorney.

Indiana Expungement Cheat Sheet

Expungement in Shelbyville, Shelby County, Indiana

Indiana Expungement Rules: Your Guide to a Fresh Start with Stephanie Renner

What Is Indiana Expungement?

Misdemeanor Expungement in Indiana: Rules and Requirements

Felony Expungement in Indiana: A Deeper Dive

Lower-Level Felony Expungement (Class D or Level 6)

Major Felony Expungement (Class A-C or Level 1-5)

Why Choose Stephanie Renner as Your Indiana Expungement Attorney?

Beyond the Basics: Unique Aspects of Indiana Expungement

Restoring Rights

Multiple Counties, One Chance

Collateral Consequences

Automatic Expungement

Frequently Asked Questions About the Indiana Expungement Law

Additional Indiana Expungement Resources

Expungement in Shelbyville, Shelby County, Indiana

Shelbyville, the proud seat of Shelby County, Indiana, is a bustling small city that blends the warmth of rural tradition with the pulse of modern progress. Nestled in the heart of central Indiana, Shelby County spans 413 square miles of rolling farmland, dotted with vibrant communities like Fairland, Morristown, and Waldron, and home to roughly 45,000 residents. Named for Revolutionary War hero Isaac Shelby, the county thrives on its agricultural heritage—corn, soybeans, and livestock remain economic pillars—while embracing manufacturing and innovation, with major employers like Knauf Insulation and Ryobi Die Casting driving job growth. Shelbyville itself, with a population nearing 20,000, hums with activity, its downtown a charming mix of historic storefronts, local eateries like Cow Palace Café, and cultural gems like the Strand Theatre, a 1916 vaudeville house now hosting concerts and plays. The county’s spirit shines in events like the Shelby County Fair, where 4-H kids show prize hogs, and the Bear Chase, a quirky festival tied to a legendary 19th-century bear hunt, complete with races and reenactments. Anchoring this civic tapestry is the Shelby County Courthouse, a Second Empire marvel built in 1931, its mansard roof and limestone façade a striking presence on Public Square. This courthouse serves as the cornerstone of the county’s judicial system, managing a spectrum of legal matters, from property disputes to criminal cases, including the nuanced process of expungement, which offers individuals a chance to seal certain criminal records under Indiana’s Second Chance Law.

Shelby County’s history is a tale of grit and growth. Founded in 1822, it drew settlers to its fertile lands along the Big Blue River, which still winds through Shelbyville, offering kayaking and fishing spots. The county played a pivotal role in Indiana’s early days, with Shelbyville briefly serving as a state capital contender. Its heritage is preserved in places like the Grover Museum, where exhibits chronicle everything from pioneer life to the county’s auto racing legacy—Shelbyville’s fairgrounds once hosted Indy 500 drivers. Economically, the county balances its agrarian roots with a robust industrial sector. Companies like Penske Logistics and Nidec operate sprawling facilities, while the Indiana Grand Racing & Casino, a major regional draw, pumps millions into the local economy with its horse racing, gaming, and entertainment. Shelbyville’s schools, part of the acclaimed Shelby Eastern and Northwestern Consolidated districts, nurture a tight-knit student body, while Ivy Tech’s local campus trains workers for advanced manufacturing. The county’s parks, like Blue River Memorial Park with its trails and splash pad, foster community, hosting summer concerts and youth sports that knit residents closer.

The Shelby County Courthouse, home to both the Circuit and Superior Courts, is a hub of judicial efficiency in a county that bridges rural and urban dynamics. The Circuit Court, led by Judge Trent Meltzer, oversees major felonies, civil suits, and family law, while the Superior Courts, under Judges R. Kent Apsley and Andrew M. Eads, handle misdemeanors, small claims, and juvenile cases. The courthouse’s grand interior—marble columns, brass chandeliers, and a soaring rotunda—lends gravitas to proceedings, yet its scale remains approachable, reflecting Shelbyville’s community-first ethos. Shelby uses the Odyssey case management system, allowing attorneys to track filings online via mycase.in.gov, though public access is limited for privacy. The clerk’s office, managed by Lori K. Myers, processes thousands of documents annually, from deeds to court orders, with a precision honed by the county’s growing caseload. The prosecutor’s office, under Bradley D. Landwerlen, tackles cases with rigor, while the sheriff’s department, led by Sheriff Louis A. Koch, ensures courtroom security and serves legal papers, maintaining order in a county where crime rates, though moderate, reflect its proximity to Indianapolis.

Expungement, governed by Indiana Code 35-38-9, is a carefully structured process in Shelby County, enabling petitioners to limit public access to certain criminal records, such as arrests without convictions or old misdemeanors. The county adheres to state law without unique local rules, requiring petitions to be filed in the court of conviction—typically the Circuit or Superior Court for local offenses. Eligibility depends on factors like the offense’s nature and time elapsed: five years for misdemeanors, eight for Level 6 felonies, and longer for serious crimes, which may require prosecutorial consent. Petitions must comply with the Indiana Rules of Trial Procedure. Given the one-time opportunity to expunge convictions, working with an experienced attorney is advised.  

The courthouse’s role extends far beyond expungement, anchoring Shelby County’s commitment to justice and community. The probation department, overseeing thousands of supervised individuals, ensures compliance with court orders, a factor that can affect expungement if fines remain unpaid. Shelby’s courts also innovate, with problem-solving dockets like the Veterans Treatment Court, which offers rehabilitation for justice-involved veterans, reflecting a restorative ethos. The sheriff’s office engages residents through programs like Citizens Academy, demystifying law enforcement, while the county’s community corrections offers work release and home detention, reducing jail overcrowding. These initiatives highlight Shelbyville’s balance of accountability and second chances, subtly aligning with the goals of expungement without directly shaping its legal path.

Shelby County’s vibrancy lies in its contradictions—a rural heart with urban ambitions. The Shelbyville News, a daily paper since 1880, captures the county’s pulse, from high school sports to zoning debates. Local festivals, like the Blueberry Festival in Morristown, celebrate small-town quirks with pie-eating contests and live bands. The arts thrive modestly, with the Shelby County Players staging dramas in historic venues and public murals brightening downtown alleys. Economically, the county is a magnet for growth, its strategic location along I-74—30 miles from Indianapolis—attracting logistics firms and retailers. Yet, challenges persist: pockets of poverty linger, and the opioid crisis strains social services, with the courts often mediating recovery efforts through drug treatment programs.

Nature is a quiet ally in Shelby County. The Big Blue River, flanked by greenways, invites reflection, while Meltzer Woods, a 60-acre old-growth forest, preserves rare ecosystems. County parks, like Sunset Park with its skate ramp, buzz with kids’ laughter, fostering the community ties that define Shelbyville. These spaces offer residents a chance to reset, complementing the personal renewal that legal processes like expungement facilitate. The county’s agricultural fairs, like the one in Flat Rock, showcase prize pumpkins and quilts, grounding residents in traditions that endure amid change.

Shelby County isn’t immune to modern struggles. Rural broadband gaps hinder remote work, and retaining young talent is tough as Indy beckons. The Board of Commissioners, meeting in the courthouse’s annex, pushes for progress—upgrading roads, expanding healthcare access—while preserving the county’s heritage, evident in the annual lighting of the courthouse’s Christmas star, a beacon visible for miles. Community groups, like Shelby County United Fund, rally for education and housing, ensuring no one is left behind in a county that prides itself on inclusion.

In Shelby County, the courthouse is a living monument, its halls echoing with stories of justice, loss, and redemption. Expungement, a small but vital part of its work, offers a fresh start for those eligible, best pursued with an experienced attorney. Surrounded by fields, factories, and festivals, Shelbyville remains a place where community endures, and the courthouse stands as its steadfast soul, balancing tradition with the promise of tomorrow.

If you have questions about the expungement process, call the Indiana Expungement Queen today for a free consultation 317-771-8535.

Indiana Expungement Rules: Your Guide to a Fresh Start with Stephanie Renner  

Are you tired of a past mistake holding you back? Whether it’s a misdemeanor or felony conviction, Indiana’s Second Chance Law offers a path to clear your criminal record and reclaim your life. Indiana Expungement Lawyer Stephanie Renner, the Indiana Expungement Queen, focuses on helping Hoosiers like you navigate the complex Indiana expungement process. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about expunging your record in Indiana—covering misdemeanor expungement, felony expungement, eligibility requirements, unique insights into the process, and how Stephanie Renner can help you achieve a fresh start. Call 317-771-8535 today to schedule your free consultation and take the first step toward freedom.

What Is Indiana Expungement?

Expungement in Indiana, often referred to as the “Second Chance Law,” is a legal process that allows individuals to expunge or seal certain records. When a case is expunged, it is still visible to the public. When a case is expunged and sealed, it means that the case is no longer visible to the public and will not appear on mycase.in.gov It is important to remember that law enforcement, prosecutors, Judges, and some government actors can still view sealed records). Expungement and sealing will give you a cleaner slate for employment, housing, education, and more. Unlike other states where expungement might only apply to minor offenses, Indiana’s laws are notably progressive, offering relief for both misdemeanors and many felonies—provided you meet specific criteria. 

Stephanie Renner, an Indiana expungement attorney with a proven track record, has earned her nickname the Indiana Expungement Queen by successfully guiding clients through this transformative process. Her expertise ensures that your petition is filed correctly, maximizing your chances of approval. Stephanie Renner also provides a MONEY BACK GUARANTEE ON ALL EXPUNGEMENTS. 

Misdemeanor Expungement in Indiana: Rules and Requirements

Misdemeanors are less serious offenses than felonies, but they can still cast a long shadow over your life. Fortunately, Indiana law makes it relatively straightforward to expunge misdemeanor convictions, and courts are required to grant these petitions if you meet the eligibility criteria. Here’s what you need to know:

Eligibility for Misdemeanor Expungement

  • Waiting Period: At least 5 years must have passed since the date of your conviction—not the arrest or sentencing date, but the day the court entered your conviction.
  • Clean Record: You must have no convictions in the 5 years prior to filing your petition. This includes convictions from any jurisdiction, not just Indiana.
  • No Pending Charges: You cannot have any active criminal cases or charges pending against you at the time of filing.
  • Fines and Fees: All court-ordered fines, fees, restitution, and costs associated with the misdemeanor must be paid in full.

Unique Insight:

One little-known aspect of misdemeanor expungement is that the 5-year waiting period can sometimes be waived with written consent from the prosecuting attorney. This is called early expungement. Stephanie Renner’s relationships with prosecutors in Indiana can allow her to negotiate this waiver, speeding up the process for her clients. While Stephanie guarantees that expungement will be granted, she can not guarantee that it will be granted early.

The Process:

To expunge a misdemeanor, you must file a petition in the county where the conviction occurred. The petition must list every record you want expunged. In Indiana, you only get one shot at expungement for convictions in your lifetime. Once filed, the prosecutor has 30 days to object. If no objection is raised and all criteria are met, the court must grant the expungement, sealing your record from public access.

Benefits of Misdemeanor Expungement

Once expunged, your misdemeanor conviction is hidden from employers, landlords, and the general public. You can legally answer “no” when asked if you’ve been convicted of a crime. This opens doors that were previously closed, from job opportunities to volunteer positions at your child’s school.

Felony Expungement in Indiana: A Deeper Dive

Felony convictions carry heavier consequences, but Indiana’s expungement laws offer hope even for these more serious offenses. However, the rules are stricter, and the process varies depending on the felony’s severity. Let’s explore the two main categories: lower-level felonies (Class D or Level 6) and major felonies (Class A-C or Level 1-5).

Lower-Level Felony Expungement (Class D or Level 6)

Class D felonies (pre-2014) and Level 6 felonies (post-2014) are the least severe felony classifications in Indiana. These include offenses like theft, possession of marijuana, or certain DUIs.

Eligibility for Low Level Felony Expungement

Here’s what’s required to expunge class D or level 6 felonies.:

  • Waiting Period: At least 8 years must have passed since the conviction date.
  • Clean Record: No convictions in the 8 years prior to filing.
  • No Pending Charges: No active criminal cases against you.
  • Fines and Fees: All financial obligations must be satisfied.

Key Difference:

Like misdemeanors, courts must grant expungement for Class D or Level 6 felonies if you meet these conditions—no judicial discretion is involved. However, if your felony was reduced to a misdemeanor at sentencing (via Alternative Misdemeanor Sentencing), the 5-year misdemeanor rule applies instead. Also, there are some exceptions to the general rule. For example, cases that resulted in injury can be expunged, but not sealed. Additionally, cases involving injury are to the discretion of the Judge and are not mandatory. Lastly, some offenses (such as sex offenses) are not eligible even if all other criteria are met.

Major Felony Expungement (Class A-C or Level 1-5)

Major felonies—such as burglary, robbery, or drug dealing—are tougher to expunge. Additionally, major felony cases are NEVER eligible for sealing. Unlike lower-level offenses, courts have discretion to approve or deny these petitions, even if you meet the basic requirements.

Eligibility for Major Felony Expungement

  • Waiting Period: At least 8 years since the conviction or 3 years since completing your sentence (whichever is later).
  • Clean Record: No convictions in the 8 years prior to filing.
  • No Pending Charges: No active cases.
  • Fines and Fees: All financial obligations paid.

Unique Twist:

For major felonies, records aren’t fully sealed—they’re marked “expunged” and remain accessible to the public. Stephanie Renner’s advocacy skills shine here, as she presents compelling arguments to sway judges in your favor, drawing on her experience as a former law clerk handling complex criminal cases.

Ineligible Felonies

Not all felonies can be expunged. Indiana law excludes:

  • Sex or violent offender registry offenses (e.g., rape, child molestation).
  • Official misconduct by public servants.
  • Two or more unrelated felonies involving deadly weapons.
  • Homicide-related crimes (e.g., murder, manslaughter).

If you’re unsure about your felony’s eligibility, Stephanie offers a free consultation to review your case and provide clarity.

Why Choose Stephanie Renner as Your Indiana Expungement Attorney?

Expungement is a one-time opportunity in Indiana, and mistakes can bar you from trying again. You only get one shot, do not miss your chance. This opportunity comes once in a lifetime. Stephanie Renner brings unmatched expertise and a client-first approach to every case:

  • Proven Experience: With a background in state and federal criminal defense, Stephanie has handled everything from petty theft to white-collar crimes, giving her a broad perspective on expungement challenges.
  • Personalized Service: Unlike big firms, Stephanie offers direct access and tailored strategies, often meeting clients with her “para-beagles” in tow for a welcoming touch.
  • Affordable Rates: Flexible payment plans and reasonable fees make expungement accessible to everyone in Indiana.
  • Local Advantage: Based in Indiana, she knows the courts intimately, streamlining the process across Indiana.

Unique Offering: Stephanie’s insider tip? She often uses character references and rehabilitation evidence—like job history or community service—to strengthen discretionary felony cases, a strategy rarely highlighted or utilized by other expungement firms.

The Indiana Expungement Process: Step-by-Step

Filing for expungement can feel daunting, but Stephanie simplifies it into manageable steps:

  1. Eligibility Check: Stephanie reviews your criminal history to confirm you meet the time, payment, and clean-record requirements.
  2. Petition Preparation: Stephanie drafts a detailed petition, ensuring that the Indiana Code is complied with.
  3. Filing: The petition is filed in the county of conviction (or each county if multiple apply), with all petitions due within a 1-year window.
  4. Prosecutor Review: The prosecutor has 30 days to object. 
  5. Court Decision: For mandatory expungements (misdemeanors, Level 6 felonies), approval is guaranteed if criteria are met. For major felonies, a hearing may be required, where Stephanie advocates on your behalf.
  6. Record Sealing: Once approved, your record is sealed or marked “expunged,” effective immediately.

Timeline Insight: Most cases take 30 to 90 days. Stephanie’s proactive filing keeps delays to a minimum.

Beyond the Basics: Unique Aspects of Indiana Expungement

Here are some lesser-known facets of Indiana expungement that Stephanie leverages for her clients:

Restoring Rights

Expungement often restores civil rights, like voting or jury service, lost due to a felony. For gun rights, the picture is murkier—federal law may still restrict ownership, even post-expungement. Stephanie provides case-specific advice to clarify your status. In some cases (such as domestic convictions) a separate petition to restore firearm rights is sometimes necessary. However, Stephanie can also represent you on the petition to restore firearm rights.

Multiple Counties, One Chance

If you have convictions in different Indiana counties, you must file separate petitions in each, all within 365 days. Miss this window, and unfiled records stay public. Stephanie coordinates multi-county filings seamlessly.

Collateral Consequences

Expungement doesn’t erase everything. Courts, law enforcement, and certain licensing boards can still access sealed records. Stephanie educates clients on these limits, ensuring no surprises down the road.

Automatic Expungement

Since 2022, Indiana automatically seals some non-conviction records (e.g., dismissed arrests) upon disposition, no petition required. Stephanie checks if you’ve already benefited, saving time and costs.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Indiana Expungement Law

1. What is sealing?

Sealing is a legal process that removes a criminal conviction from your public record. This can be beneficial for various reasons, including employment, housing, and education.  

2. What types of convictions can be expunged in Indiana?

Indiana law allows for the expungement of certain misdemeanor and felony convictions. However, not all convictions are eligible. Some factors that can affect eligibility include the severity of the crime, the time elapsed since the conviction, and whether there were any subsequent convictions.  

3. How long do I have to wait before I can file for expungement?

The waiting period for expungement depends on the type of conviction. For misdemeanors, it is generally 5 years after the date of conviction. For felonies, the waiting period is typically longer, often 8 years or more. To find out when your specific waiting period ends, call 317-771-8535.  

4. Can I expunge a conviction if I have been arrested multiple times?

Multiple arrests do not necessarily disqualify you from expungement, but they can affect your eligibility. It’s important to consult with an attorney to determine your specific situation.

5. Can I expunge a conviction if I have been convicted of a crime in another state?

If a conviction occurred in another state, you will need to follow the expungement procedures in that state.

6. Will expungement completely erase my criminal record?

No, expungement does not completely erase your criminal record. While sealing removes the conviction from public access, it may still be visible in certain databases or for specific purposes, such as background checks for certain professions or government positions.  

7. Can I expunge a conviction if I have been arrested but not convicted?

Yes, you can typically expunge an arrest record if you were not convicted of a crime.  

8. What is the difference between expungement and sealing?

In Indiana, the term “expungement” means that you have not been convicted of a crime. The term “sealing” prevents the public from accessing the record.  Click here, for a more detailed explanation of the differences between expungement and sealing. 

9. How much does expungement cost?

The cost of expungement can vary depending on factors such as the complexity of the case and whether you hire an attorney. There may also be court fees and other expenses involved.  Court fees are typically 162 per county.  There is generally a sheriff service fee of $28.  

10. Do I need an attorney to file for expungement?

While it is possible to file for expungement on your own, it is generally recommended to consult with an attorney who focuses on expungement law. An Indiana expungement attorney can help you navigate the legal process, ensure that your application is complete and accurate, and represent you in court if necessary. Another attorney once told me that doing an expungement is like changing the brakes in a car – as long as you have done it a few hundred times and you know what you are doing – it will go smoothly.  If you are doing google searches for how to do it yourself, then you don’t know what you are doing and the process is likely to end badly. 

11. How long does the expungement process take?

The timeline for expungement can vary, but it typically takes 30 to 90 days. Factors that can affect the processing time include the complexity of the case, the workload of the court, and whether there are any objections from the state.  

12. Can I expunge a conviction if I have a pending criminal case?

You cannot expunge a conviction while there is a pending criminal case against you.  

13. Can I expunge a conviction if I have been convicted of a crime of violence?

Certain crimes of violence may not be eligible for expungement. The specific eligibility criteria can vary depending on the nature of the crime. To see a list of what cases can and can not be expunged, click here.

14. Can I expunge a conviction if I have been convicted of a sex crime?

Expungement is generally not available for sex crimes.

15. Can I expunge a conviction if I have been convicted of a federal crime?

Federal convictions are typically handled by the federal court system, and can generally not be expunged.

Take Control of Your Future Today

Don’t let a criminal record define you. Whether it’s a misdemeanor or felony, the Indiana Expungement Queen, Stephanie Renner, the premier Indiana expungement attorney, is here to guide you through Indiana’s expungement rules with expertise and empathy. Call 317-771-8535 for your free consultation. Your second chance starts now! You can also click the following to view Indiana Expungement Law information by County or Statewide Indiana Expungement Law information. 

Additional Indiana Expungement Resources

Looking for more information about Indiana expungement laws or the process of clearing your criminal record? Below are some valuable resources from trusted sources that complement the expertise offered by Stephanie Renner . These links provide in-depth guides, charts, and tips to help you better understand your options under Indiana’s Second Chance Law.

While these resources offer excellent background information, nothing beats the personalized guidance of Stephanie Renner, the Indiana Expungement Queen. Contact her today at 317-771-8535 to ensure your expungement petition is handled with precision and care.

DISCLAIMER – The information contained on this website is provided for educational and informational purposes only, and should not be construed as legal advice or as an offer to perform legal services on any subject matter. The content of this web site contains general information and may not reflect current legal developments or information. The information is not guaranteed to be correct, complete or current. We make no warranty, expressed or implied, about the accuracy or reliability of the information at this website or at any other website to which it is linked. Recipients of content from this site should not act or refrain from acting on the basis of any information included in the site without seeking appropriate legal advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from an Indiana Criminal Defense attorney or attorney licensed in the recipient’s state. Nothing herein is intended to create an attorney-client relationship and shall not be construed as legal advice. This is not an offer to represent you, nor is it intended to create an attorney-client relationship.