Top 5 Rated Indianapolis Criminal Lawyers and Indiana Expungement Attorneys?

Identifying a criminal defense attorney or expungement lawyer who perfectly aligns with your needs is a complex and nuanced decision. It’s imperative to identify a criminal attorney whose expertise and approach closely mirror your specific requirements. This harmonious alignment ensures that your chosen attorney possesses a deep understanding of your concerns, facilitating open and transparent communication. This dynamic is critical in developing a comprehensive and effective defense strategy.
The gravity of entrusting your attorney with the responsibility of navigating a potentially life-altering situation cannot be overstated. It’s essential to repose unwavering trust and confidence in their professional acumen, reassured that your best interests remain their paramount concern. The legal landscape is replete with attorneys boasting diverse focus areas and levels of experience. Identifying an attorney well-versed in criminal law, with a proven track record in handling cases analogous to yours, significantly enhances the likelihood of a favorable outcome.
The intricacies of legal proceedings can be overwhelming and emotionally taxing. An attorney who resonates with your unique needs will provide a dual benefit: expert legal counsel and empathetic emotional support. This synergy empowers you to navigate the complexities of the legal process with greater ease and composure. Furthermore, your attorney should be an ardent advocate of your preferred legal approach. While some clients may favor an assertive stance, others may prefer a more measured, diplomatic strategy. A harmonious attorney-client relationship ensures that your attorney’s methodology remains consonant with your overarching objectives.
Securing the services of a well-suited criminal attorney can profoundly influence the trajectory of your case, as well as your holistic experience within the legal system. Additionally, it’s prudent to select an attorney whose fee structure aligns with your financial means.
In acknowledging my inherent bias in recommending legal professionals (a bias that naturally inclines towards myself and attorneys with whom I maintain a close working relationship), I’m also cognizant of the fact that I may not be the optimal fit for every client. Cultivating a rapport with your attorney, and selecting a lawyer whose expertise, approach, and fee structure resonate with your unique needs and budgetary constraints, is of paramount importance. Indianapolis boasts many qualified attorneys, several of whom are recommended below:

1. Stephanie Renner

Stephanie Renner focuses on criminal defense, expungement, school expulsion prenuptial agreements, and divorce cases. As an affordable criminal attorney, Renner offers flexible payment plans for numerous cases. Renner earned her law degree from Indiana University’s Robert H. McKinney School of Law. Following graduation, she gained extensive experience in criminal defense at both the state and federal levels as a law clerk for J. Edgar Law Offices.
Prior to attending law school, Renner attended Butler University, graduating with a Bachelor of Arts degree in 2016. Before pursuing her law career, she worked as a bailiff in the Marion Superior Court, Civil Division, under Judge Joven. Renner is known for bringing her canine companions to the office, affectionately referring to them as her “para-beagles.”
For individuals seeking an Indianapolis Criminal Lawyer and Expungement Attorney, Stephanie Renner’s office provides dedicated representation. Renner also provides free phone consultations.

Stephanie Renner is a distinguished criminal defense attorney who also handles Federal cases in Indianapolis, Indiana, renowned for her expertise and client-focused approach. She offers affordable legal services with flexible payment plans.

In federal cases, where sentencing is nearly universal, Renner excels at navigating the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines. She crafts compelling arguments, emphasizing mitigating factors like limited criminal history or rehabilitation to secure reduced sentences. For charges like drug trafficking or firearms offenses, Renner negotiates favorable plea deals, often minimizing penalties by highlighting clients’ cooperation. Her strategic approach ensures optimal sentencing outcomes.

Renner’s law office is highly skilled in defending against state and federal forfeiture, protecting clients’ assets from seizure. In federal cases, her team challenges government claims, asserting defenses to safeguard property like cash or vehicles. At the state level, Renner fights aggressive forfeiture practices, ensuring robust protection of clients’ rights.

Renner’s practice stands out for its affordability, offering flat-fee pricing and payment plans. Her approachable, nonjudgmental demeanor creates a supportive environment. With experience from Marion Superior Court to complex white-collar cases, she handles diverse charges, from DUIs to federal conspiracies, with dedication.

Stehanie Renner practices in the entire State, including Indianapolis, Marion County, Hamilton County, Hendricks County, Boone County, Monroe County, Madison County, Johnson County, Hancock County, Shelby County, Greenfield, Bloomington, Noblesville, Carmel, Fishers, Lebanon, Franklin, Shelbyville, Danville, Plainfield, Fairland, Morristown, Martinsville, Mooresville, Brooklyn, Anderson, Elwood, Pendleton, Greenwood, Bargersville, Beech Grove, Lawrence, Castleton, Speedway, Broad Ripple, Brownsburg, Avon, Zionsville, and Whitestown.

If you would like to contact affordable Indianapolis Criminal Lawyer and Expungement Attorney Stephanie Renner, you can visit her website by clicking here.

2. Jeff Cardella

Jeff Cardella‘s distinguished legal career began in Indianapolis, where he established himself as a formidable criminal defense attorney. With a proven track record in every stage of the criminal justice process, Cardella has successfully handled jury trials, court trials, suppression hearings, post-conviction relief, forfeiture proceedings, civil rights actions, appeals, oral argument, probation revocation hearings, expungement, and plea negotiations.
Cardella’s office has garnered prestigious recognition as one of Indiana’s top ten law firms by the American Institute of Criminal Law Attorneys. He has also received accolades as one of the top ten criminal defense attorneys in Indiana under forty by the National Academy of Criminal Defense Attorneys. Cardella’s expertise extends beyond his practice, as he has taught criminal law at the Indiana University School of Law and served as a Judge pro tem in Indianapolis.
Notable cases in Cardella’s repertoire include representing a fellow criminal defense attorney, an Indianapolis Metro Police Officer, and two former Marion County Sheriff’s deputies. He played a pivotal role in the landmark Federal Class Action lawsuit Washington v. Marion County Prosecutor, which led to the declaration of Indiana’s vehicle forfeiture statute as unconstitutional under the Due Process clause. Cardella also co-authored the amicus brief for the United States Supreme Court case Timbs v. State of Indiana, culminating in the Supreme Court’s ruling that Indiana’s forfeiture attempts were unconstitutional.
Cardella’s commitment to justice extends to advocating for the rights of marginalized communities. He successfully litigated over a dozen lawsuits against the Indiana Department of Corrections, challenging solitary confinement procedures under the Due Process Clause. Additionally, he filed several successful lawsuits against the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department for arrests violating the First Amendment.

As one of the state’s leading expungement attorneys, Jeff Cardella has built a distinguished career by successfully managing thousands of expungement cases for clients seeking a fresh start. His commitment to client satisfaction is demonstrated through a robust money-back guarantee offered on every expungement case, providing peace of mind to those he serves. Jeff Cardella maintains highly competitive pricing, ensuring that his top-tier legal services are affordable for individuals from all walks of life. His expertise shines in handling complex expungement matters that span multiple counties, where he adeptly addresses jurisdictional nuances and legal intricacies to achieve successful record clearances for his clients.

At the forefront of Cardella’s practice is a steadfast dedication to providing exceptional legal representation at reasonable prices. He acknowledges that each client is an individual with unique circumstances, deserving of a robust defense.  
More information about Cardella’s services and practice areas is available here. If you have any questions about your case, and wish to speak with an Indianapolis Criminal Defense Attorney, Indiana Expungement Attorney, Indiana Forfeiture Lawyer, or Indiana Civil Rights Lawyer, and are looking at the higher end of the price spectrum, and wish to speak to Indianapolis Criminal Lawyer & Expungement Attorney Jeff Cardella, you can visit the website for the Law Office of Jeff Cardella Criminal Defense Attorney & Expungement Lawyer in Indianapolis Indiana by clicking here. Jeff Cardella offers free consultations on all Indiana cases.

3. Josiah Swinney 

Josiah Swinney is a renowned trial lawyer focusing complex criminal cases. His expertise spans both trial and appellate levels, with a proven track record of securing successful outcomes for high-profile clients. Swinney’s exceptional skills have earned him a coveted spot in the Super Lawyers® Rising Stars list for 2022, 2023, and 2024. This esteemed recognition honors the top 2.5 percent of attorneys under 40, as selected through a rigorous process.
Swinney’s academic achievements include graduating with honors from Indiana University’s Robert H. McKinney School of Law. He launched his career as a law clerk for Solicitor General Thomas M. Fisher, where he played a key role in drafting multiple cases presented before the US Supreme Court. Swinney’s counsel extended to advising the Indiana Attorney General on strategic decisions regarding multi-state cases. His outstanding performance ultimately led to his appointment as Deputy Attorney General, where he served his community with distinction.
Presently, Swinney maintains a thriving practice in Indiana’s trial courts, the Court of Appeals, and the Indiana Supreme Court. His notable successes are documented on Casetext and Westlaw. He offers free consultations on all legal matters.
For people who are willing to spend top dollar on criminal defense representation, Josiah Swinney is a top choice.

Josiah Swinney is a highly skilled attorney in Indianapolis, Indiana, recognized for his outstanding representation in federal criminal defense, state and federal forfeiture matters, and personal injury law. His dedication to his clients, strategic legal approach, and commitment to accessibility make him a top choice for individuals navigating complex legal challenges. Swinney’s ability to deliver results while prioritizing client needs sets him apart as a trusted advocate.

In federal criminal defense, Swinney provides robust representation for clients facing serious charges, such as drug offenses, financial crimes, or other federal violations. His deep knowledge of federal law and courtroom procedures allows him to craft effective defense strategies tailored to each case. Whether negotiating settlements or advocating in trial, Swinney’s thorough preparation and persuasive skills ensure that clients receive strong representation, helping them navigate the complexities of the federal justice system with confidence.

Swinney’s expertise in forfeiture law is a cornerstone of his practice, particularly for clients at risk of losing assets like homes, vehicles, or savings due to state or federal seizures. He approaches these cases with a combination of legal precision and practical strategies, challenging unjust forfeiture actions through detailed arguments and evidence. By offering a contingency fee structure, often with a minimal initial retainer, Swinney ensures that his services are accessible, tying his success to the recovery of his clients’ assets. This client-focused approach underscores his commitment to protecting financial security.

As a personal injury attorney, Swinney excels in representing clients who have suffered serious bodily injuries, such as those from car accidents or workplace incidents. Recognizing the financial strain these cases can bring, he offers reduced fees to make legal support more affordable. Swinney’s methodical process involves gathering critical evidence, including medical records and accident details, to build compelling claims. His ability to negotiate fair settlements or litigate effectively ensures that clients receive just compensation for their pain, suffering, and losses.

Josiah Swinney’s blend of legal expertise, compassionate service, and accessible fee structures makes him an exceptional choice for federal defense, forfeiture matters, and personal injury cases. His transparent communication and relentless advocacy provide clients with peace of mind during challenging times. For those seeking a dedicated attorney to protect their rights and secure favorable outcomes, Swinney offers comprehensive legal support. Contact his office for a consultation to discuss your case and explore how he can help you achieve justice.

For individuals seeking to contact Indianapolis Criminal Attorney Josiah Swinney, you can visit his website by clicking here. 

4. Christina Gomez

Christina Gomez is a seasoned criminal defense litigation attorney and expungement lawyer practicing in Indiana, serving counties including Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Madison, Henry, and Monroe. Her expertise lies in criminal law, with a focus on defense, expungements, DUI/DWI, drug- and alcohol-related offenses, and sentence modifications. Additionally, Gomez handles litigation related to civil rights violations, due process infringements, and abuse of power by law enforcement and government entities.
Gomez understands the financial strain of legal issues and offers affordable representation, including payment plans for criminal cases. Her personal experiences growing up in the inner city of Los Angeles, California, have given her a unique perspective and driven her to advocate tirelessly for individuals facing crises, accusations, or governmental actions.
Gomez earned her Bachelor of Arts degree in History from California State University Dominguez Hills in Southern California. She later graduated with a Juris Doctor (J.D.) from the Robert H. McKinney School of Law. When not practicing law, Gomez enjoys spending time with her family and exploring Indiana’s State Parks.
For guidance on criminal matters in Indiana, consider contacting Affordable Indianapolis Criminal Lawyer Christina Gomez for a free consultation by clicking here.

5. Bob Hill

Bob Hill, a veteran attorney, leads the Marion County Public Defender Agency with expertise. While he rarely handles cases directly, he directs a talented team of deputy criminal lawyers who skillfully manage criminal cases in Indianapolis. Public defenders provide an outstanding solution for many individuals who require quality legal representation but face financial constraints.

DISCLAIMER – The information contained on this website is provided for educational and informational purposes only, and should not be construed as legal advice or as an offer to perform legal services on any subject matter. The content of this web site contains general information and may not reflect current legal developments or information. The information is not guaranteed to be correct, complete or current. We make no warranty, expressed or implied, about the accuracy or reliability of the information at this website or at any other website to which it is linked. Recipients of content from this site should not act or refrain from acting on the basis of any information included in the site without seeking appropriate legal advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from an Indiana Criminal Defense attorney or attorney licensed in the recipient’s state. Nothing herein is intended to create an attorney-client relationship and shall not be construed as legal advice. This is not an offer to represent you, nor is it intended to create an attorney-client relationship.